The Times West Virginian

Bob Herzel

November 21, 2012

HERTZEL COLUMN: Does WVU trio belong in Heisman race?

MORGANTOWN — On Monday evening, coach Dana Holgorsen pulled Stedman Bailey aside and told him that he was one of three finalists for the Biletnikoff Award given annually to the nation’s best receiver.

Considering that he has coached two previous Biletnikoff winners in Justin Blackmon and Michael Crabtree, it is something he is getting quite used to, but during this season there was a time when it appeared he would go a step beyond that and coach the Heisman Trophy winner.

In truth, he has three players for whom a Heisman case can be made in Bailey, a 1,000-yard receiver who leads the nation with 20 touchdown receptions despite being slowed two weeks by an ankle injury; in receiver/return specialist/running back Tavon Austin, who has surpassed 100 catches and 1,000 yards while also turning in a 344-yard rushing game that included 572 all-purpose yards; and early-season favorite to win the award in quarterback Geno Smith, who has broken virtually every passing record at WVU.

Five semifinalists are announced for the Heisman, which probably is sports’ most famous individual trophy and perhaps the most revered, and there would be no argument if any of the three — or all of them — were among the finalists.

At the same time, it is highly likely that none of them will win it and maybe not even reach the stage of finalist because the definition of the Heisman winner is unclear.

Is it the best player in America? Is it the best offensive player in America? Is it the best player on a winning team in America? Is it the best or the most valuable player?

Certainly, it is pretty tough to win it if you are a defensive player, only cornerback Charles Woodson of Michigan having taken the award as such in 1997, and it’s equally as hard if you are from a losing team, Notre Dame’s Paul Hornung having won in 1958 off a 2-8 Irish team.

Beyond that, linemen need not apply and receivers stand almost no chance at all.

The last receiver to win the award was Desmond Howard of Michigan in 1991. Howard, Tim Brown of Notre Dame, Leon Hart of Notre Dame and Larry Kelly of Yale, who won the second Heisman, are the only receivers to win it in its 77-year history.

Is this fair?

That was what Holgorsen was asked, being the coach of this West Virginia University team that now is fighting to finish with just a winning record despite the presence of three of the greatest offensive players in school history.

“There is nothing you can do about it. You have to win games,” he answered. “We had some guys that could have been up for the discussion if you win games. That is why I refuse to talk about it and refuse to do anything about it until later in the year.”

Take the case of Texas A&M’s quarterback Johnny Manziel, who is now the favorite.

Is he best? Probably not, but he quarterbacked an upset of No. 1 Alabama on national television and came on late in the year, drawing exposure and headlines for a team with a high profile and winning record.

“Texas A&M’s approach with (Johnny) Manziel was quite appropriate,” Holgorsen said. “There weren’t any talks of that, and then he plays well this time of the year and you get the word out there. Last year with (Baylor’s) Robert Griffin III, it was the same way. He played well late, and they were on national television and a lot of people were watching him.

“It is the best player in the country. With that said, a lot has to do with timing, and a lot has to do with playing well at the right time. You have to win games, and that is just reality.”

The reality, yes, but again, is it fair? Should Geno Smith miss out on a chance to win the Heisman because his defense can’t keep an opponent to fewer than 50 points?

“I think that’s fair,” Smith surprisingly said. “Obviously the game is about winning and losing and not so much statistics because if you look at it that way there’s guys all over the country putting up great stats. It’s really about how you lead your team and how you win games. It’s about making big plays in big games, being a game changer.”

All that is true, but didn’t Smith, Bailey and Austin make big plays in a big game against Oklahoma and be game changers, only to have something they could not control let the game slip away by a point?

Bailey, on the other hand, thinks the player’s skills and accomplishments should be what’s considered by the Heisman voters.

“I do think it should be the best player. Sometimes the best player may not be on the best team. It shouldn’t matter what school you go to or what your team’s record is,” he said, but added the obvious by saying it was out of his control.

Email Bob Hertzel at bhertzel@hotmail.com or follow him on Twitter @bhertzel.

1
Text Only
Bob Herzel
  • HERTZEL COLUMN: WVU depth chart sends messages

    Perhaps the most impressive thing about the depth chart West Virginia University put out at the end of spring practice was that the coaches were able to put out a depth chart, which certainly is an improvement over a year ago when the Mountaineers were really short on quality players.

    April 25, 2014

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: NCAA football is thriving in the digital age

    The other day Baylor football coach Art Briles walked into his graduate assistants’ office and had to laugh at what he saw.
    “There’s five guys sitting in there — a couple of GA’s and some office personnel — and they all are within a foot and a half of each other and not a one of them is talking to each other,” Briles said, describing the scene “Every one of them is on the phone.”

    April 24, 2014

  • O’Brien leads WVU baseball past Marshall

    Catcher Cam O’Brien made a bid at becoming only the second West Virginia University player to hit for the cycle as the Mountaineers jumped on Marshall early and routed their in-state rival, 10-3, behind strong pitching from Corey Walter and a pair of relievers.

    April 24, 2014

  • HERTZEL COLUMN- WVU faithful again have a reason to root against Vick

    It would be one final indignation, that’s what it would be if Michael Vick were to beat out Geno Smith and win the starting quarterback job with the New York Jets.

    April 23, 2014

  • HERTZEL COLUMN- Luck open to WVU fans’ suggestions

    West Virginia’s fans have spoken, perhaps not verbally but nonetheless have had their voices heard, over the past few years as attendance has fallen at the Mountaineers’ football and basketball games.

    April 22, 2014

  • Mountaineers ready for slate of rivalry games

    Looking to put together a late-season run to get into the NCAA championships, West Virginia faces a pair of midweek rivalry games in a crucial five-game week coming off winning two of three games at Oklahoma.

    April 22, 2014

  • HERTZEL COLUMN- Summer, Alabama will be used to get WVU’s mind right

    The ink had barely dried on the final reports out of West Virginia’s spring practice when thoughts turned forward toward the lazy, hazy days of late summer, days that will bring us into football season with a game that can either change the entire image of WVU football or sour it even further.

    April 21, 2014

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: Watson tees off a new century at The Greenbrier

    You knew this was going to be one of those unpredictable, memorable days when you drove into the Greenbrier Resort and headed to the Old White Golf Course and found the best parking place in the joint.
    As Bob Uecker would say, right there in the front rooooow.

    April 20, 2014

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: Under pressure, NCAA decides to change rules

    At first glance, it appears that they do not go hand-in-hand, a pair of rules changes the NCAA’s Legislative Council approved this week, sending them off for what seems to be smooth sailing toward becoming rules.

    April 18, 2014

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: WVU gymnast hopes to stick her final landing

    The reaction, one suspects, was the same as most people who see either a picture of West Virginia University gymnast Hope Sloanhoffer or meet her for the first time in person — a quick double take, maybe even stumbling over the first few words of an introduction.

    April 17, 2014

House Ads
Featured Ads