The Times West Virginian

Bob Herzel

November 16, 2012

HERTZEL COLUMN-WVU has to gamble on 4th down

MORGANTOWN — Earlier this year, on a rather large stage seeing as it was an important NFL Saturday night game in the middle of January, the New England Patriots stunned the Indianapolis Colts when quarterback Tom Brady, with his team stationed near midfield and facing a third-and-long play, punted.

You read that right. He punted … on third down.

What’s that you say, West Virginia University can’t get its coach Dana Holgorsen to punt on fourth down?

I know. Yes, I know … and so does he and he’s not thrilled about it, either.

Football traditionalists are stunned, shocked and hyperventilating over the way Holgorsen seems to ignore field position over and over to go for it on fourth down. He’s done that 29 times this season in nine games — an average of more than three times a game — and made it half the time, 52 percent, to be exact.

The figure is skewered somewhat by the last game at Oklahoma State where West Virginia went for it seven times in that one game, making it four times.

One, in particular, a fourth-and-long at his own 39, was widely second-guessed, and Holgorsen himself admits that he questions that decision.

“If you look at all seven of them, there is only one of them that I questioned after the game, and that was the one in the fourth quarter that we were backed up to our 35 or 40 or somewhere in there.” He said. “Looking back at it, I kind of questioned that one a little bit, but I think at that point, we were down 14, they had just had an 80-yard score, and we made the decision to go for it.”

As for the rest of the gambles …

“Other than that, the other six, I would do it again,” he said.

Especially one that had an amazing outcome, looking at fourth-and-12 at the Oklahoma State 35, quarterback Geno Smith having to leave the game because he had lost his helmet on the previous play.

Sophomore backup Paul Millard came off the bench and somehow threw a bullet of a pass to Stedman Bailey, not for a first down, for a touchdown.

“I didn’t feel good about the field goal, because of the wind. I didn’t feel good about the punt, because you have a chance at only gaining 15 yards, so we took a chance, and it worked out,” he said.

You win some; you lose some.

But there is a bigger question here, one that is raging through football, and that is whether or not the punt is overused, especially in the game the way it is where you often need 50 points to win a game.

As this year has played out, Holgorsen has been like a man playing poker and looking down on every fourth down and finding a hand of “aces and eights,” the dead man’s hand.

Strategy says punt the ball … but has anyone been watching what happens when WVU punts the ball?

At one point this year the team ranked last in college football in net punting, and even

now, with Tyler Bitancurt having established himself as a solid punter, the Mountaineers rank 97th out of 120 teams in net punting, averaging just 35 yards a punt.

Normally, you would still go ahead and punt in most situations, but then there’s this.

When you punt, you send the worst defense in college football out onto the field. True, they have a longer field to defend if you punt rather than go for it and fail, but yardage doesn’t seem to matter when you give up 478 yards and 44.4 points a game.

Holgorsen denies that enters into his thinking, but isn’t that really just coach speak? Like don’t you have to weigh your chance of getting two, three, five, heck, 15 yards with Geno Smith at quarterback and Tavon Austin and Stedman Bailey at receiver against holding the opponent if it gets the ball anywhere from the WVU 40 back to the opponent’s 30.

As much as a traditionalist such as yours truly would like to see that punt, the offensive option is really tempting for the reward far outweighs the risk.

“It’s our job offensively to score,” is the way Holgorsen puts it. “It is our job to keep going forward.”

The trouble is through this four-game losing streak, the offense has at times been as inept as the defense. Twice the Mountaineers scored 14 points. Two of the touchdowns weren’t even scored by the offense.

“Then a couple of the goal line ones, we had third-and-short and fourth-and-short, we have to be able to get it. If we are going to be successful offensively, we have to be able to get those,” Holgorsen said.

The truth is that he understands he’s been going for it far too often on fourth down.

“I don’t want to get into a habit of going for it on fourth down five to seven times a game,” he said. “I don’t want to, and if you look back at the games, there have been a couple of times this year that we have done that, but over the course of the 20-some games since I have been here, that hasn’t been the norm and don’t expect it to be.”

What’s happened, he said, is “it is all the situation. The situation has dictated it.”

The situation isn’t only down and distance, but also a terrible defense and unreliable punting.

Email Bob Hertzel at bhertzel@hotmail.com or follow him on Twitter@bhertzel.

1
Text Only
Bob Herzel
  • HERTZEL COLUMN: O’Toole joins long list of eccentric WVU kickers, punters

    The star of the Big 12’s annual football media day wasn’t a star at all.
    He intrigued the media far more than Bob Stoops, the coach of preseason favorite Oklahoma, and more than Baylor quarterback Bryce Petty, the preseason player of the year.

    July 25, 2014

  • WVU, N.C. State to meet in football

    Following a trend of creating non-conference games against regional opponents, West Virginia University has reached agreement with North Carolina State to play a home-and-home football series in 2018 and 2019.
    The Mountaineers are scheduled to play N.C. State in Raleigh on Sept. 15, 2018, and then play host to the Wolfpack on Sept. 14, 2019.

    July 24, 2014

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: ‘Cheating pays’ remark should draw attention

    When Bob Bowlsby, the outspoken commissioner of the Big 12, presented his opening-day picture of the future of college sports in Dallas for the annual media day gathering, his bleak comments were not unexpected.

    July 24, 2014

  • Holgorsen’s program hits turning point

    You can almost sense, as you watch West Virginia University football coach Dana Holgorsen sit before the gathered Big 12 media contingent answering questions in the Omni Hotel in Arlington, Texas, that he senses his program has reached a turning point.

    July 23, 2014

  • Big 12 Media Days Foo_time(1).jpg Trickett’s play key factor for Mountaineers’ success

     In the end, it comes down to the quarterback.
    Always has with Dana Holgorsen, always will.
    Quarterback is the offense with the West Virginia University coach. When he does well, the team wins – almost always.
    When he does poorly, the team doesn’t stand much of a chance.

    July 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • Saban, family happy at Alabama

    Alabama football coach Nick Saban, whose team opens the season against West Virginia in Atlanta on Aug. 30, denied receiving or turning down this offseason an offer of $100 million to coach Texas, indicating he planned to finish his career as coach of the Crimson Tide.

    July 18, 2014

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: ‘Quarterback child prodigy’ comes to WVU amidst very high expectations

    Has West Virginia football coach Dana Holgorsen finally put the arrow he needs in his quiver with the commitment received Wednesday from high school quarterback David Sills, who is a rather extraordinary story and may also just be a rather extraordinary quarterback?

    July 18, 2014

  • WVU kicker Molinari ‘All-American boy’

    West Virginia kicker Mike Molinari may not be an All-American but he is an All-American boy.
    He was honored for that on Wednesday when the Allstate Insurance Company and the American Football Coaches Association announced the West Virginia redshirt senior kicker/punter Michael Molinari is a nominee for the Allstate AFCA Good Works Team.

    July 16, 2014

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: Smallwood puts future in jeopardy

    The last thing West Virginia’s struggling football program needed as twilight was setting on Bastille Day in Morgantown was to have one of its own whisked off to the North Central Regional Jail on a fugitive warrant from another state, especially a player who had figured to play a key role in the resurrection of a program gone bad.

    July 16, 2014

  • WVU player arrested in Delaware case

    West Virginia University running back Wendell Smallwood has been arrested by university police and is being held at North Central Regional Jail awaiting extradition on a felony warrant out of Delaware.

    July 15, 2014

House Ads
Featured Ads