The Times West Virginian


December 22, 2013

Study calls for natural gas industry to provide better data about impact on water resources

FAIRMONT — According to a new study, operators in the natural gas industry need to improve their data reporting related to the impacts on water resources.

Representatives from Downstream Strategies LLC and San Jose State University collaborated to write a report titled “Water Resource Reporting and Water Footprint from Marcellus Shale Development in West Virginia and Pennsylvania.” The study was released Oct. 30.

Authors Evan Hansen, president of Downstream Strategies, and Dustin Mulvaney, assistant professor at San Jose State University, got involved in the study through the Switzer Foundation, which funded their research.

Hansen and Mulvaney are both Switzer fellows, meaning they each received fellowships when they were in graduate school to support the work of environmental leaders. Through this connection, they had access to funding from the foundation to do a study involving the collaboration between two Switzer fellows.

Hansen and Mulvaney jointly developed the idea for their project and proposed it to the Switzer Foundation for grant funding.

Mulvaney, who has been at San Jose State University for four years, said he was interested in this topic because he had done some related work previously. He teaches courses on energy in the environment, sustainable energy strategies and solar energy analysis.

“We’ve had a strong interest in learning as much as we could about the development of the Marcellus Shale,” Hansen said of Downstream Strategies.

He started this environmental consultant business in 1997. Downstream Strategies, which is based in Morgantown and has a second office in Alderson, focuses on three main program areas: energy, water and land.

Meghan Betcher, environmental scientist for Downstream Strategies, was also an author of the study. The team spent about a year to a year and a half working on the project, which was done in collaboration with Earthworks.

Marcellus Shale development has ramped up significantly in West Virginia and Pennsylvania, and there’s a lot of debate about the impact of Marcellus Shale development on water resources, Hansen said.

“We recognized that both West Virginia and Pennsylvania passed new laws and regulations related to the Marcellus Shale development, and part of those new requirements are for the natural gas operators to collect and report data about water withdrawals, fluid injection and waste disposal,” he said.

Hansen explained that the point of the study was to collect, analyze and learn from the new data that’s now being submitted, and assess whether or not these requirements are adequate and if they’re being enforced and used appropriately.

“The purpose of the work was to see if we could reconstruct water use across the various wells and then relate that to the amount of gas production,” Mulvaney added.

He said people will definitely continue to use a lot of natural gas into the future. With the most recent technological advancements in this industry, it’s important to understand the effects of extracting all of this natural gas on water use because water will be a scarce, limited resource.

While research has been done in the past on water quality, not many people had actually looked into the topic of how much water is being used in the Marcellus Shale gas development, Mulvaney said.

The study shows that in West Virginia, around 5 million gallons of water is injected for each fractured well. Mulvaney said he was surprised to learn how much of the water used in fracking stays permanently underground and never comes back up to the surface. In the state, 92 percent of that water stays permanently underground, and only 8 percent is recaptured.

Hansen said similar numbers were found in Pennsylvania.

He commented that another interesting finding involved the source of the water used in shale drilling and hydraulic fracturing in West Virginia and Pennsylvania.

“In both states, by far, most of the water is withdrawn from streams and from ground water,” Hansen said. “Even though more and more of that fluid is recycled, the recycled water still makes up a small percentage of the total fluid that’s injected.”

He also said that of all the flowback fluid reported as waste from these processes in West Virginia, almost a quarter is shipped to Pennsylvania and a quarter to Ohio. Only a little more than half of that waste stays in West Virginia.

In terms of findings related to the adequacy of the reporting requirements, Pennsylvania requires the reporting of all waste that comes from the Marcellus Shale development indefinitely, Hansen said.

The study estimated, based on the Pennsylvania data, that the West Virginia data represents only about 38 percent of the total waste that’s generated, he said. This shows that there’s a lot of waste generated in the state that isn’t reported. Also in West Virginia, a significant number of wells had not yet reported their water and fluid flows, even though they should have.

“That points to the need for stronger efforts to be made to make sure that operators report their data,” Hansen said.

Mulvaney believes this report could potentially shift the conversation related to the impact of Marcellus Shale development on water resources.

Based on the findings, he believes it’s equally important to disclose how much water is being used per well. If companies aren’t reporting their water use, the study could encourage them to start improving their practices.

“I hope what it would do is lead to some changes in the reporting requirements that would require full reporting of waste in West Virginia, and that would compel operators to actually submit data that’s required,” Hansen said.

To access the full report, visit

Email Jessica Borders at or follow her on Twitter @JBordersTWV.

Text Only
  • ‘L-gov’ program of West Virginia Treasurer’s Office providing many benefits

    The “L-gov” program of the West Virginia State Treasurer’s Office is providing many benefits to governmental entities across the state, including the City of Fairmont.
    L-gov, which is an abbreviation for local government, helps cities, towns, school boards, public service districts and other entities process their bills in a streamlined, efficient way.

    July 27, 2014

  • Cardinal Tax Services-JB.jpg Helping people focus of Cardinal Tax Services

    At Cardinal Tax Services LLC, Wendy Cutlip is doing what she enjoys — helping people.
    Cutlip, owner and Registered Tax Return Preparer, opened her new business in White Hall at the beginning of June. It is located in the Mountain Gate Business Park, which is along Route 250 South just past Fabric and Foam and next to the Sunoco.

    July 27, 2014 1 Photo

  • Your chocolate addiction is only going to get more expensive

    For nearly two years, cocoa prices have been on the rise. Finally, that's affecting the price you pay for a bar of chocolate - and there's reason to believe it's only the beginning.

    July 22, 2014

  • Wal-Mart to cut prices more aggressively in back-to-school push

    Wal-Mart Stores plans to cut prices more aggressively during this year's back-to-school season and will add inventory to its online store as the chain battles retailers for student spending.

    July 22, 2014

  • Morgantown’s housing expenses exceed national average

    The housing prices in Morgantown are driving the city’s cost of living above the national average, a new survey reports.
    John Deskins, director of the West Virginia University College of Business and Economics’ Bureau of Business and Economic Research (BBER), explained that the Council for Community and Economic Research (C2ER) orchestrates data collection in 288 cities across the country.

    July 20, 2014

  • JA Used Furniture-JB.jpg J.A. Used Furniture has valuable variety

    J.A. Used Furniture in Fairmont carries items that people need — all at low prices.
    Owner Ron Dray officially opened the doors of his new business, located at 10 Locust Ave., toward the end of December. He explained that the “J.A.” initials in the store’s name stand for the names of his two granddaughters, Jordan and Adriauna.

    July 20, 2014 1 Photo

  • Backbone Security, T&T Pump Co. among 37 state companies recognized

    Two Marion County companies were recently celebrated for their continued successes in exporting.
    Backbone Security and T&T Pump Co., both in Fairmont, were among the 37 West Virginia companies that Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin, Cabinet Secretary Keith Burdette, the West Virginia Development Office and the West Virginia Export Council recently acknowledged for expanding their business to new parts of the world. An awards presentation was held in Charleston on June 24.

    July 13, 2014

  • All Things Herbal-JB.jpg All Things Herbal health and wellness shop

    All Things Herbal Local Market is a one-stop, health and wellness shop.
    Owner Christa Blais officially opened her new business in downtown Fairmont at 327 Adams St., across from Veterans’ Square, on June 6 during Main Street Fairmont’s First Friday event.

    July 13, 2014 1 Photo

  • 3-D printing continuing to revolutionize manufacturing

    As 3-D printing is revolutionizing manufacturing, the Robert C. Byrd Institute for Advanced Flexible Manufacturing continues to stay at the forefront of this technology.
    RCBI has three Advanced Manufacturing Technology Centers, located in Bridgeport, Charleston and Huntington.

    July 6, 2014

  • Blackheart International -JB.jpg Blackheart International bringing high-quality services

    Blackheart International, a firearms manufacturer and provider of logistics and training solutions, is bringing high-quality services to the local community.
    At the beginning of April, the company moved from Philippi, where it had been located since 2005, to its new home in Fairmont.

    July 6, 2014 1 Photo

Featured Ads
NDN Business
House Ads