The Times West Virginian

Opinion

April 24, 2014

Laws to keep mudslinging to minimum can stife free speech

By nature, and by profession, we do not like lies. As journalists, we’re truth tellers. Or at least we attempt to get at the truth through research, attribution, documents and comments from people on either side of an issue.

Sometimes it ends up with “telling lies from both sides,” as a crusty reporter once mused a handful of years ago. That seems especially true during election seasons, as we are currently experiencing. That is not to say that all those who seek office tell lies. But many times, the things said within a campaign season are generalizations and assumptions and are put out there for the shock value.

“My opponent’s proposed tax platform would put mom and pop stores out of business.”

“My opponent wants to pass laws that would put semi-automatic assault rifles in the hands of children.”

Those seem like far-fetched statements. And it’s entirely possible that there is a thread of truth to each statement, but it’s weaved into a shocking accusation and carefully scripted for the most voter impact.

Policing false statements made during a political campaign, whether they be in print, on websites, on billboards or spoken, is a very dangerous practice. And during arguments earlier this week over an Ohio law in front of the U.S. Supreme Court, justices said that laws in 15 states are questionable and possibly an attack against free speech and debate within political campaigns.

The case in a nutshell is this: During the 2010 election, a national anti-abortion group, the Susan B. Anthony List, wanted to place billboards against Congressman Steve Driehaus, D-Ohio, of supporting taxpayer-funded abortion because he voted in favor of the health-care overhaul. Driehaus claimed the billboard would violate Ohio’s law against reckless falsehoods during an election and filed a complaint with the Ohio Elections Commission. The commission found that there was probable cause that there was a violation of law, which stopped the billboard company from posting the ad. The anti-abortion PAC challenged the state law as unconstitutional, but a judge said that there wasn’t any harm done to the group so it didn’t have the right to sue.

So the issue comes to the Supreme Court. Unfortunately, its final ruling will not answer the question of whether these laws that attempt to police statements before and after they are made during elections violate the First Amendment. The only question the court can answer is whether the group has the right to challenge the law even though the case was dismissed.

We surely wish they’d be able to rule on the law itself and those like it. Of course, justices had the opportunity to speak out against it this week during oral arguments. They say that having to answer to a commission and possibly face charges for things said during a heated election would have a chilling effect on free speech.

“What’s the harm?” Justice Stephen Breyer asked Eric Murphy, attorney for the state of Ohio. “I can’t speak, that’s the harm.”

Justice Anthony Kennedy followed that with the statement that there was “a serious First Amendment concern with a state law that requires you to come before a commission to justify what you are going to say.”

Why do wish that there’s be a ruling on the Ohio law? Well, other states with similar laws include Alaska, Colorado, Florida, Louisiana, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Montana, North Carolina, North Dakota, Oregon, Tennessee, Utah, West Virginia and Wisconsin.

That’s right, West Virginia. We agree with a statement that Chief Justice John Roberts made, that it is not just the candidates and the PACs who suffer under such laws. It is also the third parties, like newspapers and TV stations or billboard owners that can be intimidated by the law, and that, too, will stop a candidate or group from getting their message out to the voters.

And that just shouldn’t be the case. There needs to be an opportunity for wide-open debate during the political process. We don’t endorse lies, but we also fear that laws to keep mudslinging down to a minimum will also trample on freedom of speech of all candidates and those groups and committees that support them.

1
Text Only
Opinion
  • Time is now for Tomblin to support King Coal Highway

    U.S. Rep. Nick Rahall, D-W.Va., is asking Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin to add the King Coal Highway project to West Virginia’s six-year highway improvement plan. It is a logical request, and one that Tomblin should act promptly on.

    July 29, 2014

  • United effort to keep NASA in Fairmont is essential project

    The high-technology sector is obviously vital to the economy of North Central West Virginia.
    That’s why a strong, united effort to keep the NASA Independent Verification and Validation Program in Fairmont is absolutely essential.

    July 27, 2014

  • COLUMN: Calling all readers: Be heard

    I love to talk to readers.
    I love to hear concerns they have about stories we’ve written, things they think should be included in the newspaper and things they think shouldn’t be.

    July 27, 2014

  • Korean War veterans are deserving of a memorial

    NEEDED: A total of $10,000 for the Korean War Memorial this year.
    And a good man has been placed in charge of the funding. Charlie Reese, former president of the Marion County Chamber of Commerce, is now director of the Marion County Development Office. His task was to make a recommendation as to what steps are necessary to keep the project moving.

    July 25, 2014

  • Roll up your sleeves, give blood and you can save lives

    It takes up to 100 units of blood to save the life of someone who sustains life-threatening injuries in a vehicle accident.
    We’re hoping that the number of people who come to Fairmont Senior High School on Friday for and American Red Cross blood drive will exceed that amount.

    July 24, 2014

  • Vehicles and motorcycles must share the road safely

    The days are long. The weather is superb. There’s plenty of leisure time in these lazy days of summer.
    It’s the perfect time to take a long motorcycle ride.
    It’s also the perfect opportunity for us to take the time to remind not only riders but drivers of the need to share the road. And we feel compelled to mention it because just within the month of July, there have been two motorcycle-versus-car accidents within the City of Fairmont alone — one with severe injuries sustained by the motorcyclist and the other with less serious injury.

    July 23, 2014

  • Too many taking too few steps to protect selves from skin cancer

    July 22, 2014

  • Distracted driving: It isn’t worth fine or a life

    Today marks the day that police agencies from six states are joining forces to crack down on one thing — distracted driving.
    And they will focus on that traffic violation for a solid week, with the stepped-up effort to curb distracted driving wrapping up on Saturday, July 26.

    July 20, 2014

  • COLUMN: Are we people watchers or people judgers?

    Let me tell you about my little friend Robby. Well, actually, it’s more about his family and especially his mom. I didn’t get her name. I heard Robby’s name quite a bit, though, during a trip home from Birmingham, Alabama.
    I noticed the family in the Birmingham airport immediately. They were just the kind of family you’d notice.

    July 20, 2014

  • Relish the rich bounty of state’s diverse, unique food traditions

    This week, a group of federal officials on a three-day culinary tour of the state visited the Greenbrier Valley to find out what most of us here already know — we have a rich food tradition in West Virginia.
    The group was made up of officials from the Appalachian Regional Commission, the Environmental Protection Agency and the U.S. Department of Agriculture.

    July 18, 2014

Featured Ads
NDN Politics
House Ads