The Times West Virginian


April 28, 2013

Should bombing suspect be treated as ‘enemy combatant’?

Anyone who has watched a cop show or two probably is familiar with a Miranda warning. Every state has variations with the exact phrasing, but it typically sounds like:

• You have the right to remain silent.

• Anything you say or do may be used against you in a court of law.

• You have the right to consult an attorney before speaking to the police and to have an attorney present during questioning now or in the future.

• If you cannot afford an attorney, one will be appointed for you before any questioning, if you wish.

• If you decide to answer any questions now, without an attorney present, you will still have the right to stop answering at any time until you talk to an attorney.

• Knowing and understanding your rights as I have explained them to you, are you willing to answer my questions without an attorney present?

The warning, or otherwise referred to as “Miranda rights,” is read to suspects taken into police custody so that their statements will be admissible in court. It dates back to a 1966 Supreme Court case when the high court found that failing to advise a suspect of their rights was a violation of the fifth and sixth amendments and that if a suspect is not made aware of those rights, anything said may not be used against them in court.

It does not mean that a suspect must be Mirandized. And in the case of Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, the surviving suspect in the Boston Marathon bombing, while he was properly charged within 48 hours of being taken into police custody, he was not read his Miranda rights prior to being questioned by federal officials?

Why? There are things the American public will never know about the alleged acts of these brothers. But it’s likely that between evidence collected after the suspects were identified and surveillance footage taken at the bombing sites and the subsequent police chase in Watertown, Mass., they probably didn’t need Dzhokhar Tsarnaev to say whether or not he was responsible for the crimes to successfully prosecute him.

“First and foremost, your priority is to stop other threats and protect the public,” Michael Rosensaft, a former federal prosecutor in New York, told the Los Angeles Times. “After that, you can focus on the prosecution.”

It’s possible that federal officials wanted to know about the plot first, to determine if the threat level had been eliminated, or whether there needed to be further steps taken to protect the American public.

But though many have criticized the decision, all questioning stopped after 16 hours in detention when Dzhokhar Tsarnaev was arraigned by federal Magistrate Judge Marianne B. Bowler in his hospital bed. He was then moved to Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston to be treated for the four bullet wounds he sustained during the police chase. It is a high-security medical detention facility.

The only way to have stopped the process of arraignment and the legal steps that had to be taken by law enforcement officials and the courts would have been to declare Dzhokhar Tsarnaev an “enemy combatant.” And would the courts look favorably on that? An American citizen committing crimes on American soil being tried as an enemy combatant? It may have set some very frightening legal precedents.

We asked our readers about this issue, the ones who log on each week to to weigh in on how suspect Dzhokhar Tsarnaev should be treated by the court system. On our online poll question, we asked “Should Dzhokhar Tsarnaev be tried as a terrorist by the federal government, which limits his legal rights, or by Massachusetts authorities?”

And here’s what you had to say.

* The crimes happened in Massachusetts and should be prosecuted as such — 5.34 percent.

* Federal charges offer the death penalty as a sentence — something that must be considered — 10.69 percent.

* He is an American citizen, not an enemy combatant, who deserves the legal rights afforded to citizens — 15.27 percent.

* This was an act of war, and he should be tried by the feds as a terrorist — 68.7 percent.

Of course, this case isn’t over. In fact, analysts say it may take years for the process to play out. So keep on reading, it’s sure to come up again.

This week, let’s talk about West Virginia’s Feed to Achieve program, which is getting some national attention. What are your thoughts on the program, which would blend private donations and federal funds to feed every child in school breakfast and lunch?

Log on. Vote. Email me or respond online.

Misty Poe

Managing Editor


Text Only
  • Korean War veterans are deserving of a memorial

    NEEDED: A total of $10,000 for the Korean War Memorial this year.
    And a good man has been placed in charge of the funding. Charlie Reese, former president of the Marion County Chamber of Commerce, is now director of the Marion County Development Office. His task was to make a recommendation as to what steps are necessary to keep the project moving.

    July 25, 2014

  • Roll up your sleeves, give blood and you can save lives

    It takes up to 100 units of blood to save the life of someone who sustains life-threatening injuries in a vehicle accident.
    We’re hoping that the number of people who come to Fairmont Senior High School on Friday for and American Red Cross blood drive will exceed that amount.

    July 24, 2014

  • Vehicles and motorcycles must share the road safely

    The days are long. The weather is superb. There’s plenty of leisure time in these lazy days of summer.
    It’s the perfect time to take a long motorcycle ride.
    It’s also the perfect opportunity for us to take the time to remind not only riders but drivers of the need to share the road. And we feel compelled to mention it because just within the month of July, there have been two motorcycle-versus-car accidents within the City of Fairmont alone — one with severe injuries sustained by the motorcyclist and the other with less serious injury.

    July 23, 2014

  • Too many taking too few steps to protect selves from skin cancer

    July 22, 2014

  • Distracted driving: It isn’t worth fine or a life

    Today marks the day that police agencies from six states are joining forces to crack down on one thing — distracted driving.
    And they will focus on that traffic violation for a solid week, with the stepped-up effort to curb distracted driving wrapping up on Saturday, July 26.

    July 20, 2014

  • COLUMN: Are we people watchers or people judgers?

    Let me tell you about my little friend Robby. Well, actually, it’s more about his family and especially his mom. I didn’t get her name. I heard Robby’s name quite a bit, though, during a trip home from Birmingham, Alabama.
    I noticed the family in the Birmingham airport immediately. They were just the kind of family you’d notice.

    July 20, 2014

  • Relish the rich bounty of state’s diverse, unique food traditions

    This week, a group of federal officials on a three-day culinary tour of the state visited the Greenbrier Valley to find out what most of us here already know — we have a rich food tradition in West Virginia.
    The group was made up of officials from the Appalachian Regional Commission, the Environmental Protection Agency and the U.S. Department of Agriculture.

    July 18, 2014

  • Soup Opera in need of your support again this time of year

    It’s happening again.
    It usually always happens about this time each year. Sometimes it’s a little earlier and sometimes a little later.
    But Soup Opera executive director Shelia Tennant knows it will come — usually in July. And she’s never that surprised about it.

    July 17, 2014

  • County honors men who gave all in helping their community

    The next time you’re driving in the Rivesville area, you might notice new signs on two of the area’s bridges.
    Those signs, which bear the names of Alex Angelino and Denzil O. Lockard, were unveiled Saturday in honor of the men whose names they display, two men who died while serving their communities.
    The bridge on U.S. 19 over Paw Paw Creek was named to honor Lockard, while the bridge on U.S. 19 over Pharaoh Run Creek was named to honor Angelino. Lockard, a former Rivesville police chief, died in 1958 at the age of 48 while directing traffic. Angelino, a Rivesville firefighter, died at the age of 43 of a heart attack while fighting a fire in 1966.

    July 16, 2014

  • State must learn to keep costs down and perform more efficiently on less

    The West Virginia state government began its budget year last Tuesday with a small surplus of $40 million — less than 1 percent of its annual tax revenues — thanks only to dipping into its savings.
    Let’s not do that again.

    July 15, 2014

Featured Ads
NDN Politics
House Ads