The Times West Virginian

Opinion

January 27, 2013

Second Amendment: What are limitations?

“A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.”

Twenty-seven little words and 1,027 ways to interpret them.

That is the complete text of the Second Amendment to the United States Constitution.

For about 100 years after ratification, the Second Amendment wasn’t often the topic of debate. And then case after case came before the U.S. Supreme Court. And case after case left justices trying to clarify those 27 words and apply them to modern times.

And case after case found the justices ruling that an individual’s right to keep a weapon is paramount, but it doesn’t mean there are not limitations.

The most recent case, District of Columbia vs. Heller in 2008, is considered landmark. It was the first case in the history of the Bill of Rights to declare that the Second Amendment protects an individual’s right to keep and bear arms for self-defense.

But, again, there are limitations. It was just that the court felt the District of Columbia was infringing on individual rights with a law forbidding handguns in the home and that all guns must be unloaded, disassembled or bound by a trigger lock.

“The requirement that any lawful firearm in the home be disassembled or bound by a trigger lock makes it impossible for citizens to use arms for the core lawful purpose of self-defense and is hence unconstitutional,” the majority opinion in the case reads.

A triumph for gun-rights supporters, the opinion also includes one very important statement — maybe not as powerful as the text of the Second Amendment, but certainly a clarification of it:

“Like most rights, the Second Amendment right is not unlimited. It is not a right to keep and carry any weapon whatsoever in any manner whatsoever and for whatever purpose.”

And so, regulations being proposed by President Obama in response to the horrific mass murder at Sandy Hook Elementary School may not be in line with what people believe and the values they hold; however, it’s not exactly unconstitutional. Well, I take that back. That’s for a court to decide if Congress were to put into law the requirements. The plan includes background checks on all guns sales, reinstating an assault weapons ban, banning high-capacity magazines and armor-piercing bullets, gun trafficking laws and increased access to mental health treatment.

His proposal is getting support, but whether Congress will act on it is another story (and poll question) all together. But we thought we’d throw this question out to our readers who log on to vote at www.timeswv.com in our online poll question each week.

And here’s what you had to say in response to this question: “Gun control is peaking again as a hot topic of conversation after President Barack Obama presented his administration’s stance last week.What are your thoughts?”

• We have to prevent gun violence and mass killings in this country, and this is a good start — 10.53 percent

• I am a proud gun owner, but who needs assault rifles or high-capacity magazines to hunt or protect their property? — 14.47 percent

• Criminals don’t exactly follow laws. This will just take guns out of the hands of law-abiding citizens — 16.23 percent

• My Second Amendment right to bear arms must be respected. You can’t pick and choose which arms are OK and which ones aren’t — 58.77 percent

This is definitely a “to be continued” kind of conversation. We’ll keep our eyes on this issue and continue to discuss it as it evolves. But this week, let’s talk about another controversial issue: The Department of Defense is lifting a ban on women serving in combat positions. Is this something you can support?

Log on. Email me or respond online. Misty Poe

Managing Editor

mpoe@timeswv.com

@MistyPoeTWV

 

1
Text Only
Opinion
  • Unsung heroes handling calls in emergencies are appreciated

    Thankfully, we live in a community where help is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week, just by dialing three numbers — 9-1-1.
    During this week, which is recognized as National Public Safety Tele-Communicator’s Week nationwide, we need to remember that on the other end of that line are the men and women here in this county who are always there in case of accident, crimes, medical emergencies and any other catastrophic event.

    April 18, 2014

  • Message to ‘buckle up and park the phone’ is saving lives

    A figure that we haven’t seen that much in recent years is the highway death toll for a given period.
    Is the death toll up, down or just about the same as it was?
    The West Virginia Southern Regional Highway Safety Program has announced there were 325 highway fatalities in 2013, the second-lowest number on record.

    April 17, 2014

  • State native Burwell can ‘deliver results’ as Health and Human Services secretary

    Sylvia Mathews Burwell might not be a name with which most people are immediately familiar.
    For the past year, she has run the budget office under President Barack Obama.
    Prior to that, she served as president of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation’s Global Development Program and later the Wal-Mart Foundation.

    April 16, 2014

  • Marion scores well in recent health report but could do better

    When it comes to area-wide studies, especially on health, there’s usually good news and bad news.
    So was the recent report on the health of America’s counties released by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation recently. The nationwide county study evaluated health outcomes and health factors, and ranked counties accordingly.

    April 13, 2014

  • COLUMN: ‘Instant’ news not always reliable

    Instant.
    That little word has a pretty big meaning. With origins that date back to the 15th century, it means urgent, current, immediate.
    But think about how that word has developed over the past few decades.
    Instant pudding. Instead of slaving over a hot stove for a few minutes, you can now pour cold milk and with a bit of stirring, instant pudding!

    April 13, 2014

  • Decision to be an organ donor can save lives

    Chelsea Clair watched as her father died waiting for a bone marrow transplant.
    So when she met Kyle Froelich at a car show in 2009 and heard about his struggles to find a kidney that would match his unique needs, she never hesitated to offer hers to the man she just met.

    April 11, 2014

  • Volunteers continue to have priceless impact on community

    Chances are, you know someone who volunteers. Perhaps you’re a volunteer yourself.
    Marion County is full of volunteers.
    They read to our youth.
    They assist nonprofit agencies.
    They serve on boards and committees.
    And in 2013, they spent a day picking up nearly 10 tons of garbage that had been tossed out on public property around Marion County.

    April 10, 2014

  • Proposed school calendar lives up to letter and spirit of law

    West Virginia state law requires that students be in a classroom for 180 days.

    April 9, 2014

  • Strong Fairmont General Hospital badly needed to serve our region

    Mere minutes often matter when it comes to emergency health care.
    That’s why we need a strong Fairmont General Hospital.
    When patients need the services of health-care professionals, having family and friends close at hand is often essential, and their presence may even lead to a better outcome.

    April 6, 2014

  • COLUMN: Fairmont General Hospital vital part of community

    There’s nothing better than holding a newborn baby. It gives you a little feeling that not only is everything right in the world, but this perfect little human represents hope of a future where things will be better than they are today.
    I had that blessed opportunity to hold that hopeful future in my arms last week when I visited my dear friend Jen and her newborn son Tristan at Fairmont General Hospital.

    April 6, 2014

Featured Ads
NDN Politics
House Ads