subscriber servicessubscribecontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Sat, Nov 21 2009 

Published: February 15, 2008 01:45 am    print this story  

Judge orders Rivesville officials to provide records

By Paul Fallon
Times West Virginian

FAIRMONT A conflict between the Rivesville council and former recorder and town resident John Harless has escalated to circuit court.

Judge David R. Janes heard both sides of the case Thursday, which dealt with several Freedom of Information Act requests filed by Harless concerning Rivesville records. The requests were made for various financial documents, such as the town’s check registry. Harless also sent requests for profit-and-loss financial statements for each of the town’s departments.

Harless had received copies of the check registry. However, the names of the people the checks were made out to had been blacked out. The memo section of the checks had also been blacked out because they had Social Security numbers written on them, according to DeAndra Burton, Rivesville town attorney.

Janes ruled in favor of Harless, ordering the town officials to provide the records to the Rivesville resident. The judge informed the council members who were present at the hearing to provide Harless with copies of the town’s check registry among the numerous other records that were requested.

“This information that Mr. Harless has requested, as painful as it is, is public information,” Janes said after his ruling.

“You can redact (black out) the Social Security numbers, but not the names on the checks,” Janes said.

Janes also ruled that the council members could not charge more than 25 cents per page for copies of the documents provided to Harless. Rivesville officials recently passed an ordinance requiring that a fee of 75 cents per page for copies would be levied for all information requested from the town records.

“I think that today, 25 cents is a reasonable fee,” Janes said.

Rivesville officials are also required to reimburse Harless for court costs, Janes said. Harless did not hire a lawyer and instead represented himself at the proceedings so council does not have to reimburse him for attorney fees. Janes added that the court costs will probably cost the town approximately $205.

“I think the hearing went well,” said Harless following the proceedings. “And I am satisfied with what I received.”

Tammie Crites, Rivesville mayor, said that she did not disagree with the ruling. However, she added that she did not believe the FOIA requests from Harless would stop now that the case has been decided.

“I think that we’ll continue to be barraged with FOIA requests by Mr. Harless to no constructive purpose,” Crites said.

Crites, along with Burton, added that they had believed at the time that they were protecting the privacy of town employees when they redacted the names from the copy of the check registry provided to Harless. The two insisted that they did not intentionally try to hide financial information from him.

Harless had originally filed suit against both Crites and Barb Beatty, town recorder, in both their official capacity as well as personally. Janes had dismissed the suit against the two in their personal capacity.

E-mail Paul Fallon at pfallon@timeswv.com.

print this story  



autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Premium Jobs

HRDF
JOB DEVELOPER/
JOB COACH
Developing employment opportunities/job coaching for persons 16-24 with
disabi
...>MORE

Trailer Mechanic
Trailer Mechanic
wanted
Must have at least two years experience. Drivers license, Tools requires, Wage is neg
...>MORE

District Sales Manager
district sales
manager
We have a position available for a district sales manager to be responsible for the pr
...>MORE

Licensed Contractors
Licensed Contractors needed for
HVAC & Home Weatherization Projects
North Central WV Community Action is
...>MORE

Regiistered Nurse
Fairmont State University is seeking to fill the part time position of Registered Nurse.  Please apply online at www.fai...>MORE

Sales Consultant
Sales Consultant
Due to expansion, Bath Fitter is looking for a sales consultant in the Morgantown/Fairmont/Clarksb
...>MORE

Physical Therapy Assistant
Physical Therapy Assistant - Mountain State Physical Therapy is now accepting applications for a Full Time Licensed PTA ...>MORE

Sales Persons
Urse Honda, West Virginia’s largest Honda dealer has immediate openings for sale people. Up to three positions are avail...>MORE

Mountain State Physical Therapy
PHYSICAL THERAPIST Mountain State Physical Therapy is now accepting applications for a Full Time Staff Physical Therapis...>MORE

CNAs & LPNs
CNAs & LPNs
Positions available
throughout the region.
APPLY TODAY!
www.capitolmedical.net
800-
...>MORE

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index