The Times West Virginian

Local News

October 24, 2013

Washington’s trial in Windmill Park murders to begin Nov. 18

FAIRMONT — On. Nov. 18, Eddie Washington is scheduled to stand trial for his alleged role in the triple 1974 Windmill Park homicides.

Marion County Prosecuting Attorney Patrick N. Wilson and defense attorneys Neal J. Hamilton and Holly Turkett appeared Wednesday morning before Marion Circuit Judge Michael Aloi with some last-minute housekeeping motions.

The bodies of Guy Lester Phillips, 20, and his wife, Wanda Jane Phillips, 19, and Billy Ray Cobb, 27, all of Fairmont’s Montgomery Avenue area, were found in the early morning hours of Aug. 2, 1974, at Windmill Park.

Those murders remained unprosecuted until the arrest of Washington earlier this year in Florida. A co-defendant, Phillip Reese Bush, also awaits trial. He is incarcerated at Mount Olive Correctional Complex on a double-murder conviction in 1983.

• Motion to stipulate admissibility of certain pieces of evidence at trial.

Wilson had no objection to seven pieces of evidence, but did have concerns about 12.

• Motion to prohibit Wilson from using testimony Washington gave in a suppression hearing on Aug. 13, 2013.

Turkett said that Wilson had asked questions “outside the scope” of rules of evidence that could subject Washington to cross-examination at trial.

“Mr. Washington gets on the stand and talks about memory or intelligence or lack of memory, and they are all valid pointes to be tested at cross. They put him up there. He is not immunized from that being used to impeach him.”

Aloi said he would hold the motion in abeyance.

• Photographs of the victims in their caskets will not be shown at trial.

• Showing close-range crime scene photos of the three is still in question.

Death certificates of the three can be admitted for cause of death, Turkett said. But showing those photos could prejudice and incite the jury.

Wilson said that state law is becoming more lenient in showing crime scene photos.

“This is part and parcel to our case. This was a homicide. People were killed, and the manner in which they were killed, how they looked, is all relevant.

“They should not be precluded unless they are absolutely, overly horrendously graphic, which they are not. They are pictures of bodies in a field. We’ve heard nothing from the defense why they would prejudice the jury or make them unable to make a rational decision.”

The photos are also “extremely relevant” in case an issue is made of where the murders took place, he said.

Turkett said the state just wants to use them to incite the jury, “they have no probative value ... nothing indicates who pulled the trigger.”

Where the murders took place could become “a critical dispute,” Aloi said.

“The state's theory is that these people were killed at Conley Farm and transported to Windmill Park,” Hamilton said. “If the prosecution is changing from that theory, I need to know.”

“The evidence is what it is,” Wilson said.

“We will raise that issue if and when it comes up,” Aloi said. He said he would review the issue and make a ruling quickly.

• A jury view of key sites in the case will take place after jury selection and before opening arguments.

• A photo array (or lineup) will be suppressed from trial.

• Washington will be permitted to wear nonprison attire and have no visible restraints at the November trial.

• A potential key witness for the defense will be expected to travel from Washington County, Pa., to Fairmont to testify.

The witness, Darrell Corley, suffers from diabetes, heart condition and blindness, and is adamantly opposed to testifying, Hamilton said. He proposed Corley be allowed to give a video deposition.

Aloi denied the request, but said he would consider if Hamilton could give him more medical reasons for the video deposition.

• With three other major murder trials on the docket (Kristyn and Michael Palmer, and Phillip Reese Bush), the jury pool is getting depleted rapidly. And none is black.

Hamilton said that Washington wants to continue to go to trial.

• A special jury questionnaire will not be ordered, although Hamilton may prepare one and submit it to Aloi for review.

Email Debra Minor Wilson at

Text Only
Local News
  • Bush’s murder convictions reinstated

    Phillip Reese Bush had his two first-degree murder convictions reinstated on Wednesday.
    The Memorandum Decision was handed down by the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals. This decision reversed the Ohio County Circuit Court order from February 2013 that granted Bush a new trial.

    April 24, 2014

  • Weber would like to be Marion-Fairmont ‘buffer’

    With his six years of experience on Fairmont City Council, Daniel Weber is now running as a candidate for a seat on the Marion County Commission.
    Weber, a retired theater professor from Fairmont State University, said while he was teaching at the university he wanted to run for House of Delegates but couldn’t because he worked at FSU. It would have been a conflict of interest because delegates choose higher educators pay.

    April 24, 2014

  • Opposition to Worthington’s annexation proposal surfaces

    There was some opposition to the Town of Worthington’s annexation proposal.
    A public hearing was held Wednesday at the Marion County Commission meeting for the annexation of 43.28 acres into Worthington. Commissioners heard opinions on the matter but did not vote on the issue.

    April 24, 2014

  • Mailing on voter registration prompts questions

    Concerned voters started calling in to the Marion County Clerk’s office Wednesday after receiving a mailing from the Americans for Prosperity Foundation on voter registration.

    April 24, 2014

  • Farmington addresses problem properties

    The Town of Farmington is focusing on property maintenance, water and sewer issues.
    During its meeting on Monday night, council agreed to adopt the International Property Maintenance Code. This code, along with the town’s ordinance, will allow Farmington to better address some problem properties.

    April 24, 2014

  • (Main) Jay Rockefeller-EG.jpg ‘Something hard’ for Rockefeller turns out to be devotion to service

    U.S. Sen. Jay Rockefeller, D-W.Va., returned to West Virginia Wesleyan College Tuesday to host a public policy forum and reflect upon his time in public service.

    April 23, 2014 2 Photos

  • 042314 Chuckie Sanders-EG.jpg Sanders now eligible for parole

    Chuckie Sanders is eligible for parole today.
    Not bitter about the 20 years he’s served, Sanders, 52, acknowledges the crime he was charged with, the drug habit that clouded his judgment and the debt he had to pay to society.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • Home-rule application approved by council

    Fairmont City Council approved on Tuesday submitting the city’s home-rule application to the home-rule board.

    April 23, 2014

  • Tennant hopes to keep county commission seat

    Burley “Butch” Tennant is not a stranger to the Marion County Commission.
    As the current president of the county commission, he started serving the six-year term in 2008.

    April 23, 2014

  • Gee and McKinley at WVU Healthcare Forum-EG.jpg Access to health care challenge to state

    Access to health care, and technology to better facilitate that care, is a big challenge in the rural areas of West Virginia.

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

Featured Ads
TWV Video Highlights
NDN Editor's Picks
House Ads