The Times West Virginian

My Favorite Recipe

October 5, 2011

Somethin’ from the oven

FAIRMONT — How many people remember the jingle, “Nothin’ says lovin’ like somethin’ from the oven”?

Katie Keefover not only remembers it but also lives it.

There doesn’t seem to be anything she can’t bake.

Homemade pepperoni rolls? She came in third and second in two cookoffs at the Three Rivers Festival. Homemade pizza pie? Check. Homemade cinnamon rolls? Double check.

In fact, “Homemade” is probably her unofficial middle name.

“It’s a pleasure to serve you,” she says as she carves out a plate-size chunk of her fresh-from-the-oven apple cobbler, topped with about half a gallon of vanilla ice cream. (An exaggeration, just barely.)

Just in case you want more, she’s also got hot apple pie on the table and apple dumplings still bubbling away in her oven.

When she was 8 years old, she made her first dinner: spaghetti and meatballs. Her mother, Allie Parson Thomas, didn’t really like to cook, so her stepdad Charlie encouraged Keefover to be at home in the kitchen.

She learned to cook by watching her grandmother, who would make biscuits for every meal, and from cooking class at school. She also learned from an aunt.

“She made the best of everything! But she’d just give you wee little pieces, just enough to tempt you.”

That is something that, fortunately for everyone who likes apple pie, Keefover obviously did not learn.

Her first vegetable soup was a marriage of what was on hand.

“We only had five vegetables in the refrigerator, so I put them together. Mother and Dad said that was the best vegetable soup they’d ever tasted.”

She lived in Nutter Fort, Fairmont, Hagerstown, Md., and then Grafton, where she spent her teenage years.

“That’s when I really learned to cook ... from Miss Cook, who was the cooking teacher. I known, how appropriate. She was so sweet. She taught us to think of others when you’re cooking, not about yourself.”

Taking that advice to heart, one night she made fried potatoes, baked potatoes, mashed potatoes and parsley potatoes. Her family liked potatoes.

“They liked them, but I think they preferred other food,” she said with a laugh.

When she was 18, she met Bob Funk.

“His eyes just looked like a kitten’s,” she said. “I hurried home and told my mother, ‘I just saw the man I’m going to marry.’”

And she did, that next June. Before that, when she first invited him to dinner, she didn’t know what kind of pie he liked. So she made 16 different ones.

“I wanted to make sure I had it covered.”

She did. He liked the butterscotch. His family polished off the rest.

“Bob, oh, he loved to eat,” she said.

They had three children. Sadly, he died in a car accident on Cheat Mountain just before Father’s Day 1970. He was buried on their 13th wedding anniversary.

“I’ve had a lot of hardships in life, but God is good all the time,” she said.

“When I was making this apple pie, I was thinking that we are the apples of God’s eye.”

Her family is relatively easy to cook for, she said. She and her older son like liver and onions; others do not.

“Everybody to their taste,” she said.

“I taught all my kids to cook. And all three are better cooks than I am, I kid you not. If I had the money, I’d set them up with a restaurant.”

Her favorite holidays are Thanksgiving and Christmas. While some people make deep-fried turkeys, she makes hers the old-school way so she can have broth for gravy and dressing “and all that stuff.” For Christmas, she prefers a nice ham, sweet potatoes “and the whole nine yards.”

And all the cookies and pies she can bake.

Her apple treats were as easy to make as, OK, apple pie. Everything, from the crust to the filling, is homemade. She usually makes a double batch of dough when she bakes, she said.

“There’s just something homey about a homemade pie. I most generally make two pies at a time, sometimes three,” she said. “My trouble is I like to bake and give it away, and then later at night I’ll say, ‘Oooh, I wish I had a piece of that!’”

She laughs.

When she feels the need, she’ll go to one of her many cookbooks hidden in a kitchen cabinet and drawer.

She can improvise, too.

“I was asked to make an apple-pecan pie. I’d never heard of it before, so I got an apple pie recipe and pecan pie recipe, and mixed them together.”

She doesn’t mind sharing her recipes, and receiving them from others.

“My mother-in-law gave me this recipe in 1957,” she said of the crust. “It’s called ‘Perfect, No-Fail Pie Crust.’

“But you know how good cooks don’t measure things. I know by my hand how much to put in.”

And when she’s ready to pop the goodie into the oven, there’s one last step.

“Now, all you add is love,” she said, sprinkling sugar on top.

The contest for October is apples. To be featured on the “My Favorite Recipe” page, contact Debbie Wilson at 304-367-2549 or

Email Debra Minor Wilson at

Text Only
My Favorite Recipe
  • 091912.jessi.polis.debe104_2785.jpg Sweet enough

    If you like something sweet, Jessi Polis has the cake for you.
    Her orange cream cheese pound cake is light, refreshing and just sweet enough to satisfy those cravings.
    This cake is her husband Sam’s favorite, she said.

    September 19, 2012 2 Photos

  • 091212.paula.jpg Powerful poppers

    Paula Ansberry makes some pretty powerful pepper poppers.
    She got the recipe from a friend a couple of years ago. She was a little hesitant to try one. She’s not a spicy food kind of person.

    September 12, 2012 2 Photos

  • 082912.goddard.jpg Sweet success

    People say they go to cookouts and picnics to get together with friends and family.
    They say they like the burgers and dogs, and pasta, fruit and potato salads, and all those other side dishes you can’t have a picnic without.

    August 29, 2012 2 Photos

  • Art of cooking

    Kim Holbert isn’t one of those “Try it; you’ll like it” kind of cooks.
    She’s more like, “You like it; I’ll make it.”
    “If I know that you have a preference toward something, I aim it that way,” she said.

    August 15, 2012 2 Photos

  • 080812.judy.starn.deb.jpg Just home cooking

    Food doesn’t have to be fancy to be tasty.
    Judy Starn learned this growing up on Sugar Lane in Catawba. She was the only girl in nine children of Woodrow and Anna Starn. One brother passed away, so she grew up among seven brothers.
    “I like to cook, but I wouldn’t say I’m a good cook,” she said.

    August 8, 2012 2 Photos

  • 080112.linn.deb.jpg Just plain cooking

    You know those pretty layered salads people put in clear glass bowls, and you have to lift all the layers out at the same time and then spread them out on a plate so everybody can see how pretty it is, and then they go “ooh” and “ahh”?

    August 1, 2012 2 Photos

  • 072512.jpg ‘Just plain good’

    When it’s just too darned hot to cook, or you need something cool and light in a jiffy, Josephine Vespoint has a quick-as-a-wink salad for you.
    Take two cans of pears, and drain and place each pear right side up on a bed of lettuce.

    July 25, 2012 1 Photo

  • 071812 parrish.deb.jpg All about family

    All her life, Alma Hoy Parrish has been about one thing: family.
    She’s put the knowledge she learned at her mother’s knee to good use during her 46-year marriage to Tom Parrish while raising their two children, Mike Parrish and Lori Hill.

    July 18, 2012 2 Photos 1 Story

  • 071112 pic.deb.jpg Easy and versatile

    There are salads that you ever-so-politely nibble on.
    Not Cathy Davis’ California Tossed Salad.
    It fills a large bowl to the brim. You have to grab it with tongs, lift it to your plate and, as she says it, “dive on in.”
    It’s filling. It’s healthy. It’s easy to make.

    July 11, 2012 3 Photos

  • 070412 picnic 1.jpg Light and fluffy

    Grandmas are probably the world’s best cooks.
    Just ask anybody who’s been lucky enough to have eaten their scrumptious cookies, luscious pies, fluffy cakes and wholesome breads.

    July 4, 2012 1 Photo

Featured Ads
NDN Lifestyles
House Ads