The Times West Virginian

My Favorite Recipe

July 11, 2012

Easy and versatile

FAIRMONT — There are salads that you ever-so-politely nibble on.

Not Cathy Davis’ California Tossed Salad.

It fills a large bowl to the brim. You have to grab it with tongs, lift it to your plate and, as she says it, “dive on in.”

It’s filling. It’s healthy. It’s easy to make.

And, best of all, it’s very versatile, she said.

“This recipe is just a guideline. Put in what you like. Take out what you don’t like. You could add meat. Absolutely.

“You can change anything. If you don’t like an ingredient, don’t put it in. You can also make it into different kinds of salads.”

For a little French flair, use endive, spring mix or butter lettuce, switch to bleu cheese, add broccoli or radishes, and change the dressing to plain yogurt with bleu cheese cream dressing.

For a good old red-white-and-blue American salad, use good old American iceberg lettuce; mozzarella, provolone or even Colby cheese; and frozen peas.

“Obviously you’d want to eat it right away,” she said.

She found the recipe in a newspaper article back in 1985 or ’86, when she and her husband Jim Salai were living in Florida. It had originally come from a book.

“But I’ve never run into it anywhere before. I’ve been making it since. I’ve just stylized it. It’s nice that way because you can stylize it.”

Don’t like bacon? Substitute chicken. (“But why would you?” she asked playfully.)

“This is not a good leftover salad. It’s a good we’re-gonna-eat-it-all-today salad,” she said. “It gets weepy.”

The secret is to get all the ingredients “really, really dry,” she said.

You can get the ingredients done ahead of time; just don’t mix them together until a few hours before you’re ready to serve the salad.

“I put the ingredients in baggies yesterday and built the salad this morning,” she said. “As long as you don’t put it all together. You do have to let it sit for a couple of hours. It’s better that way. Everything runs together.”

You can add protein, like shrimp, chicken, turkey. Leave out what you don’t like.

You can use different fruit other than oranges. Strawberries or peaches or even apples would be nice.

You can use different flavored yogurt. You can use any kind of creamy dressing you want.

“But not anything with oil,” she said. “It doesn’t mix well with the yogurt. If you want to use ranch, use a plain yogurt.”

No matter what you do, it’s bound to become your “please make it” dish.

“At all the teacher’s meetings and luncheons in any state I’ve ever lived in, they all wanted this salad,” Davis said.

This salad is “totally healthy. It’s low-fat yogurt, low-fat cheese. You could use egg whites or turkey bacon.

“I don’t like frozen, processed foods, but they’re a necessity now.”

They’ve lived in their home overlooking a large pond and spacious yard for about 10 years now. Both are Marion Countians born and bred, but have lived all over the country, from Florida to New York State to Colorado to Kansas and Pennsylvania.

There have been good and bad things about all those places, but no matter where they’ve roamed, they always come back to West Virginia.

Jim has a master’s in athletic training and was in sports medicine for years. He’s also run his own clinic and did arena football.

“He got burned out,” she said with a laugh.

She holds a teaching license and has been a school librarian and social studies teacher for years. This year she will teach at East Fairmont Junior High.

“We’ve been together for 35 years,” she said. “I’ve liked every place we’ve been.

“But the neatest thing I learned was that the kids are all the same. And I can tell my students that.”

She likes to be flexible, “like the salad,” she said.

Add a beverage and some crusty bread, and you’ve got a meal. And when you scoop out that first portion and heap it onto your plate, don’t count on it being neat and clean.

“Like a pie, the first piece is always the messiest,” she said, laughing.

“You’re supposed to toss it. But you just dive for it.”

You can section the oranges, but she just peels and chops, and she’s ready to go.

“I don’t care if they have membranes on them. And don’t cut the oranges over the salad. Do it over another bowl. Drain the juice off. You need to put dry pieces in the salad.

“You could use those fruit cup orange pieces, but you have to drain them very well. You don’t want the extra water, or the salad will get soupy on you.”

She rolls up the lettuce pieces in a dishtowel after they’ve drained in the colander, to avoid any unwanted moisture.

“These are just some tricks I’ve picked up over the years,” she said.

Every Wednesday through September, Take 5 wants you to take us on a picnic. Submit your summertime recipes to Debbie Wilson at 304-367-2549 or

Email Debra Minor Wilson at


Text Only
My Favorite Recipe
  • 091912.jessi.polis.debe104_2785.jpg Sweet enough

    If you like something sweet, Jessi Polis has the cake for you.
    Her orange cream cheese pound cake is light, refreshing and just sweet enough to satisfy those cravings.
    This cake is her husband Sam’s favorite, she said.

    September 19, 2012 2 Photos

  • 091212.paula.jpg Powerful poppers

    Paula Ansberry makes some pretty powerful pepper poppers.
    She got the recipe from a friend a couple of years ago. She was a little hesitant to try one. She’s not a spicy food kind of person.

    September 12, 2012 2 Photos

  • 082912.goddard.jpg Sweet success

    People say they go to cookouts and picnics to get together with friends and family.
    They say they like the burgers and dogs, and pasta, fruit and potato salads, and all those other side dishes you can’t have a picnic without.

    August 29, 2012 2 Photos

  • Art of cooking

    Kim Holbert isn’t one of those “Try it; you’ll like it” kind of cooks.
    She’s more like, “You like it; I’ll make it.”
    “If I know that you have a preference toward something, I aim it that way,” she said.

    August 15, 2012 2 Photos

  • 080812.judy.starn.deb.jpg Just home cooking

    Food doesn’t have to be fancy to be tasty.
    Judy Starn learned this growing up on Sugar Lane in Catawba. She was the only girl in nine children of Woodrow and Anna Starn. One brother passed away, so she grew up among seven brothers.
    “I like to cook, but I wouldn’t say I’m a good cook,” she said.

    August 8, 2012 2 Photos

  • 080112.linn.deb.jpg Just plain cooking

    You know those pretty layered salads people put in clear glass bowls, and you have to lift all the layers out at the same time and then spread them out on a plate so everybody can see how pretty it is, and then they go “ooh” and “ahh”?

    August 1, 2012 2 Photos

  • 072512.jpg ‘Just plain good’

    When it’s just too darned hot to cook, or you need something cool and light in a jiffy, Josephine Vespoint has a quick-as-a-wink salad for you.
    Take two cans of pears, and drain and place each pear right side up on a bed of lettuce.

    July 25, 2012 1 Photo

  • 071812 parrish.deb.jpg All about family

    All her life, Alma Hoy Parrish has been about one thing: family.
    She’s put the knowledge she learned at her mother’s knee to good use during her 46-year marriage to Tom Parrish while raising their two children, Mike Parrish and Lori Hill.

    July 18, 2012 2 Photos 1 Story

  • 071112 pic.deb.jpg Easy and versatile

    There are salads that you ever-so-politely nibble on.
    Not Cathy Davis’ California Tossed Salad.
    It fills a large bowl to the brim. You have to grab it with tongs, lift it to your plate and, as she says it, “dive on in.”
    It’s filling. It’s healthy. It’s easy to make.

    July 11, 2012 3 Photos

  • 070412 picnic 1.jpg Light and fluffy

    Grandmas are probably the world’s best cooks.
    Just ask anybody who’s been lucky enough to have eaten their scrumptious cookies, luscious pies, fluffy cakes and wholesome breads.

    July 4, 2012 1 Photo

Featured Ads
NDN Lifestyles
House Ads