The Times West Virginian

Sports

January 31, 2013

HERTZEL COLUMN: Do top teams get the calls?

MORGANTOWN — Today’s discussion is a difficult one and is not meant to cast aspersions or put forth accusations upon the men and women who serve as officials in the sports that captivate our imagination.

We have always operated in this corner of the sportswriting world under the belief that it was best to discuss sports without involving the officiating unless it absolutely had to be involved. Incidents such as umpire Jim Joyce’s call in what should have been a perfect game, umpire Don Denkinger blowing Game 6 of a World Series and costing the St. Louis Cardinals a world championship or Russia being given three chances to inbound the ball against the USA in winning the 1972 Olympic men’s basketball championship certainly would be the exceptions.

In truth, I find myself often shouting at fans who are shouting at officials for calls they make that go against that fan’s team, in part because fans see things as they want to see them and because officials, like players, make mistakes, too. I find it abhorrent to make them correct those mistakes after a long look at instant replay when players are not given the same courtesy.

So why then are we today about to discuss, at least in general tones, the officiating that went on during West Virginia University’s hard-fought loss to No. 1/2 Kansas earlier this week?

The reason is that it seems to be on the minds of a great number of people and because it is something that has always intrigued this inquiring mind.

Certainly, following the game in which Kansas shot 34 free throws and West Virginia 15, Mountaineer coach Bob Huggins referenced the referees. He did not do so critically, although he was certainly not offering high praise, either.

“Did I think they would shoot 34 free throws and we shoot 15? No,” said Huggins following the game. “We have, up until about a week ago, made more free throws than our opponents have taken. We were No. 1 in the power six conferences.”

Translated, Huggins was trying to say that there was something different about the way this game was being officiated than other games.

Which takes us where we are trying to go.

Without making any kind of accusation, the question must be asked if the top teams in sports don’t subconsciously get breaks from officials.

We are not talking about officials fixing games or doing anything intentional to rig the finish. In truth, there we only wish our politicians were as honest as are our sports officials.

But these men are human, too, and as a fan sees things the way he wants to see things, so, too, could an official, and if you are working for a conference who benefits from having the nation’s No. 1 team or as many Top 10 teams as it can have — be it for NCAA Tournament appearances and seeding or for getting into a national football playoff — could you not be subconsciously influenced in what you see?

In truth, the Kansas game wasn’t officiated much differently than a number of other WVU games this season in the Coliseum. Privately, in fact, there has been some displeasure within the basketball facility with the way some Big 12 home games have been called, WVU not getting whatever home-court advantage it has become accustomed to having.

Is it a “welcome to the Big 12” thing or simply a different officiating philosophy than prevailed in the Big East?

Certainly, with the money that is involved in collegiate — and, of course, professional — sports today, there are forces at work that cast shadows on almost everything that goes on in the games we play.

That athletes have cheated with performance enhancing drugs has become an old story, but we’re not just talking about football and baseball, although they have just come back into the news with the story out of Miami that has re-implicated Alex Rodriguez and the Baltimore Ravens’ Ray Lewis.

But it didn’t stop at those big-money sports, as Lance Armstrong has proven to us all.

If cycling can be tainted, what is sacred?

And that brings us back to the officiating situation.

It isn’t that anything suspicious went on in the Kansas game, or in the other games, for that matter, but the art of officiating is so subjective and varies so much from one official to another, from one crew to another and often from one conference to another that it allows anyone to question it.

And so it is when one crew allows bumping and banging and another crew calls every touch foul, you wonder what is going on and think thoughts that you know can’t possibly be true.

But …

Email Bob Hertzel at bhertzel@hotmail.com or follow him on Twitter @bhertzel.

1
Text Only
Sports
  • Big ‘I’ golf coming to Pete Dye

    The Trusted Choice Big “I” National Championship will make its first trip to West Virginia when Pete Dye Golf Club hosts the 46th annual installment of the event Aug. 5-8.
    The Pete Dye course, ranked No. 45 on Golf Digest’s ranking of America’s 100 Greatest Courses and No. 9 on Golfweek’s ranking of Best Modern Courses, will host 160 of the best junior golfers from 40 states during the 72-hole stroke play event.

    July 30, 2014

  • Scott sees swift title contention for Lakers

    Byron Scott was a key component of the Los Angeles Lakers’ Showtime teams, a smooth shooting guard with sizzling competitive fire. He believes his purple-and-gold championship pedigree makes him the ideal coach to return the struggling 16-time champions to NBA contention.
    “This organization is all about championships, period,” Scott said Tuesday at his introductory news conference. “We don’t look at Western Conference finals, Western Conference championships. We look at (NBA) championships. And we know we have some work ahead of us, but I’m excited. ... I love challenges anyway, so this is going to be fun.”

    July 30, 2014

  • Opinion: People running NCAA may not be bumbling idiots

    Two down, one big one to go.
    And with it a growing realization that maybe the people running the NCAA aren’t the bumbling idiots everyone has been making them out to be.
    The NCAA’s agreement Tuesday to create a $70 million fund to diagnose concussions and brain injuries does more than just give some former and current athletes a bit of peace of mind — if no real money. It also extricates the organization from another serious threat to its existence, one that could have potentially bankrupted it if everyone who ever suffered a concussion playing college sports were somehow able to cash in.

    July 30, 2014

  • Steelers Camp Footbal_time2.jpg Bell looking for more decisive, productive season

    Le’Veon Bell kept watching the tape over and over, equal parts pleased and puzzled by what he saw.
    There were times during his rookie season when the Pittsburgh Steelers running back would place his hand on an offensive lineman’s back and wait patiently for the hole to open.
    Sometimes, one would appear. Sometimes it wouldn’t, mainly because whatever sliver of daylight existed had already been swallowed by darkness while Bell was still trying to read the blocks in front of him.

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • smallwood-wendell(1)-2.jpg Charges against Smallwood dropped

     West Virginia University running back Wendell Smallwood took to Twitter mid-afternoon Tuesday to express his feelings after charges of witness intimidation against him were dropped by the state of Delaware.
    It took him only three words to say what was on his mind: “God is Good.” Smallwood is now free to return to West Virginia and rejoin his Mountaineer teammates when they open camp for the 2014 season Thursday.

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • dungy0725 (1).jpg Rice, Dungy sideshows stain NFL

    The National Football League guards its reputation as aggressively as lineman are paid to protect a quarterback.
    So, as training camp opens around the country, how odd is it to see Commissioner Roger Goodell’s 32-team NFL empire battling bad headlines and stinging criticism from all quarters?
    Anyone want to talk to the new quarterback for his early assessment of playing with the best and biggest players in the land? That would be business as usual. Nothing has been routine about the early days of camp this season.

    July 30, 2014 2 Photos

  • Post 17 #7 Post 2 #12 mw.JPG DeVaul wraps up final season as Post 17’s leader

    If you were to ask players on Fairmont American Legion Post 17’s roster who they looked up to, you’d find a familiar pattern.
    Sure, you may get some Andrew McCutchens or some Derek Jeters as replies. But if you want to find out the real answer, just look into the dugout.

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • Big ‘I’ golf coming to Pete Dye

    The Trusted Choice Big “I” National Championship will make its first trip to West Virginia when Pete Dye Golf Club hosts the 46th annual installment of the event Aug. 5-8.

    July 29, 2014

  • Charges against Smallwood dropped

    West Virginia University running back Wendell Smallwood took to Twitter mid-afternoon Tuesday to express his feelings after charges of witness intimidation against him were dropped by the state of Delaware.

    July 29, 2014

  • Return to Mountain State exciting for new sports writer

    When I packed my belongings out of my Morgantown apartment in May, fresh with a journalism degree from West Virginia University, I thought I had ended a chapter of my life and closed the book on my experience inside the great Mountain State forever.
    It wasn’t until I received a phone call back in my hometown of Canton, Ohio, from the Times West Virginian that the idea of a return to the area became a possibility. The opportunity to begin my professional career in an area that I’ve become comfortable with for the past several years was too good to pass by.

    July 29, 2014

Featured Ads
NDN Sports
House Ads
Auto Racing Photos
Auto Racing Breaking News
Auto Racing Standings