The Times West Virginian

WVU Sports

April 12, 2011

HERTZEL COLUMN - Big East doesn’t need 10th team

MORGANTOWN — It seemed to be a foregone conclusion that by the time this week was over, Villanova would become the 10th football-playing school in the Big East.

Now that’s not quite as sure as it was ... and that’s a good thing.

Villanova may need Big East football, but Big East football doesn’t need Villanova.

The meeting that was supposed to be held Monday was canceled, reportedly because Pitt and a few other Big East schools had concerns about the stadium situation for Villanova. More to the point, the concern was directed at a lack of a quality stadium that Villanova had.

That, however, is one of many reasons Villanova is not the right school to step in and give the conference a 10th member, even though it is a top-of-the-line FBS school. It is, in fact, the national champion of that smaller division.

From the moment it was revealed that the Big East was considering adding Villanova to the football mix, an inquiring mind wondered why.

What does Villanova bring to the party?

From Big East Commissioner John Marinatto’s point of view, the biggest selling point has nothing to do with football at all. Adding Villanova to the mix avoids complicating his precious basketball commodity, already an unwieldy 18 teams that is, if you will pardon a pun, and Irish stew of mismatches.

Notre Dame, of course, plays basketball but not football, and that’s fine with Marinatto, as it gives it just another highly regarded Catholic university not in the football mix ... along with St. John’s and Seton Hall and DePaul and Marquette and ... well, you get the idea.

Add a football playing school that also would bring a basketball program and you have 19 basketball teams, which just doesn’t work, no matter how much the Big East ego tells it that it can do whatever it wants to do without penalty in the big time basketball world.

What you want out of a football program is to have one that adds something to the quality of the football league.

Villanova does not do that.

It doesn’t bring great tradition. In fact, it is a program that once was a Division I school and opted to cut back.

It doesn’t bring a big stadium. In fact, the plans are for it to play in a soccer stadium in Chester, Pa., that seats 18,000 but could be converted to 30,000 if necessary. At 30,000, that is not big enough.

It isn’t a city clamoring for a football team.

Hardly. Already noted was Villanova’s inability to sustain a Division I program. How about a similar school there, Temple, which was a Big East football member and kicked out for an inability to play at the required level.

Philadelphia, of course, is a great sports town ... but it is one that is oversaturated and a Big East football team could not really compete for the fans’ attention. It would be going against the Phillies, the Eagles, the 76ers and the Flyers in the major professional sports, and battling collegiate allegiances to Temple, Penn, St. Joseph’s and LaSalle.

Connecticut is a similar school that entered the Big East after having established itself as a basketball power, and while it has a decent following, the sport did not capture the imagination of the public, one that is similar to WVU in that it really had only a hockey team professionally with which to compete.

Rather than ramped up after winning a spot in the Fiesta Bowl this past season, the school lost $1 million on its trip to Phoenix, failing to sell more than 2,700 tickets.

Why should Villanova be different ... or even that good, for that matter?

The truth is, the Big East doesn’t need a 10th team, and the group out there to select from is hardly overwhelming, the most likely ones if Villanova doesn’t come in being East Carolina, Central Florida or Florida International ... all of them not doing a thing for basketball.

The Florida schools, at least, could get the conference into the Miami or Orlando area and be someone to twin on road trips with South Florida in the minor sports, at least cutting costs there.

But having added national power TCU as a ninth team would seem to be enough, allowing an eight-game regular season schedule and four non-conference games. Why screw it up by adding a 10th team that offers little of football value?

Email Bob Hertzel at

Text Only
WVU Sports
  • HERTZEL COLUMN- Luck open to WVU fans’ suggestions

    West Virginia’s fans have spoken, perhaps not verbally but nonetheless have had their voices heard, over the past few years as attendance has fallen at the Mountaineers’ football and basketball games.

    April 22, 2014

  • WVU athletic department to form Fan Experience Committee

    The West Virginia University Department of Intercollegiate Athletics is forming a fan experience committee to discuss the needs of Mountaineer fans with the hopes of enhancing the fan experience at its events.

    April 22, 2014

  • FURFARI COLUMN- Popovich, now 73, wishes he were playing baseball today

    If you’re a long-time baseball fan, you may recall Morgantown’s Paul Popovich.

    April 22, 2014

  • Mountaineers ready for slate of rivalry games

    Looking to put together a late-season run to get into the NCAA championships, West Virginia faces a pair of midweek rivalry games in a crucial five-game week coming off winning two of three games at Oklahoma.

    April 22, 2014

  • HERTZEL COLUMN- Summer, Alabama will be used to get WVU’s mind right

    The ink had barely dried on the final reports out of West Virginia’s spring practice when thoughts turned forward toward the lazy, hazy days of late summer, days that will bring us into football season with a game that can either change the entire image of WVU football or sour it even further.

    April 21, 2014

  • Arrest warrant out for WVU recruit

    West Virginia University’s newest men’s basketball recruit, Tarik Phillip, has an order out for his arrest in North Carolina, according to a story in The Dominion-Post, which said three Gaston County Magistrate office spokespersons confirmed.

    April 20, 2014

  • WVU baseball powers past Oklahoma, 9-5

    The WVU baseball team tied a season high with 18 hits to defeat Oklahoma, 9-5, on Saturday afternoon at L. Dale Mitchell Park.
    The win gives the Mountaineers their second Big 12 series win of the season and improves the overall record to 19-16 and 4-7 in conference play. Oklahoma drops to 25-16 overall and 5-7 in Big 12 play.

    April 20, 2014

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: Under pressure, NCAA decides to change rules

    At first glance, it appears that they do not go hand-in-hand, a pair of rules changes the NCAA’s Legislative Council approved this week, sending them off for what seems to be smooth sailing toward becoming rules.

    April 18, 2014

  • Means, WVU baseball shut out Oklahoma

    Junior left-hander John Means of the WVU baseball team threw eight shutout innings and the Mountaineers had a five-run first inning en route to a 7-0 victory over Oklahoma on Thursday evening at L. Dale Mitchell Park.
    The Mountaineers (18-15, 3-6 Big 12) broke a six-game Big 12 losing streak after being swept by TCU and Oklahoma State in back-to-back weekends. WVU had 16 hits and did not make an error for the second-straight game.

    April 18, 2014

  • FURFARI COLUMN: Dr. Graber disagrees with Gee’s stance on Turnbull firing

    Dr. Stephen Graber, an associate professor at the West Virginia University School of Medicine, is among the latest WVU teachers to deplore Oliver Luck’s firing of veteran wrestling coach Craig Turnbull.
    He raised some significant questions about that issue last Monday in a meeting of the WVU Faculty Senate.

    April 18, 2014

Featured Ads
WVU Sports Highlights
NDN Sports
House Ads
NCAA Breaking News
NCAA Photos