The Times West Virginian

WVU Sports

December 6, 2010

HERTZEL COLUMN: BCS football system must be scrapped

MORGANTOWN — After spending an hour or two trying in vain to come up with some clever way to back into what must be said today, we will take the direct route and make our point right out of the chute.

The BCS system used in college football today must be scrapped in favor of a playoff.

There is nothing wrong with declaring a game — no matter what kind of 21st century formula you use to get there — between Auburn and Oregon as a national championship game because the two, through totally different paths, wound up undefeated in the regular season.

It’s just that in reality it is no more a championship game without a playoff than if you’d picked the names out of a hat containing unbeaten, untied teams. In fact, knowing the way the NCAA runs things, if they had picked names out of a hat they’d probably wind up with TCU facing 6 7/8.

The way the BCS is set up at present, there really is only one meaningful postseason game — the championship game.

You can play around all you want but the truth is that Connecticut’s Fiesta Bowl game has no more meaning, except perhaps at the cash register, than does West Virginia’s Champs Sports Bowl encounter in Orlando, Fla., or even Pitt’s BBVA Compass Bowl game in Birmingham, Ala.

You want to know the truth, a player would probably as much enjoy playing between Christmas and New Year’s in Florida than to spend it fighting off scorpions and rattlesnakes in the Arizona desert.

A bowl win is a bowl win, period. End of story.

A bowl game serves no higher purpose than the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. It is a marketing tool that the cities and sponsors would drop in a second if something came along to draw more people to their towns or products.

One may ask what makes the BCS games other than the championship lack prestige? The first and biggest problem is that is not part of any championship structure. The Fiesta Bowl might as well be the Siesta Bowl, a who cares matchup outside of the states in which the participants play.

The other reason is because Connecticut is there while such teams as Alabama, Michigan State, Oklahoma State and Nebraska are not.

Connecticut is the champion of the Big East and, as such, may well have been invited to a playoff, if one were instituted, but the guess is they would wind up in some bowl game not associated with the championship playoff.

The NCAA pretends that putting together a football playoff would be so much more difficult than any other playoff that they just wring their hands, say “Never mind” and turn the naming of a champion over to the television people.

Goodness knows, that’s where the money is. Add that to the bowl traditions — some of them now as much as two years old — and you have a strong lobby.

But all you have to do is watch one NCAA basketball tournament or even go to the College World Series and you know that we can do better than this. Everyone knows it, even the coaches.

Dave Wannstedt, the Pitt coach who came out of the NFL which has a playoff system that seems to work just fine, culminating in something you may have heard of know as “The Super Bowl”, was asked on a conference call today where he stood on a playoff.

“I think everyone would like to see a playoff of some sort,” he said.

Then why not?

“I don’t think anyone has a plan to work through that with academics with time frame allotted,” he said. “I know the coaches voted unanimously to leave it as it is, but conversations I have with everyone says they would like to see something.”

Imagine, if you will, a tournament with the eight or 16 best teams in American. It sounds tough to do, yes, but is it really? If you were to have an eight-team tournament you would have four games on one week, two games the next and two weeks later a championship game. Only two teams would play three extra games.

And you think that isn’t better than watching Oklahoma play UConn with nothing at stake?

E-mail Bob Hertzel at

Text Only
WVU Sports
  • HERTZEL COLUMN: Under pressure, NCAA decides to change rules

    At first glance, it appears that they do not go hand-in-hand, a pair of rules changes the NCAA’s Legislative Council approved this week, sending them off for what seems to be smooth sailing toward becoming rules.

    April 18, 2014

  • Means, WVU baseball shut out Oklahoma

    Junior left-hander John Means of the WVU baseball team threw eight shutout innings and the Mountaineers had a five-run first inning en route to a 7-0 victory over Oklahoma on Thursday evening at L. Dale Mitchell Park.
    The Mountaineers (18-15, 3-6 Big 12) broke a six-game Big 12 losing streak after being swept by TCU and Oklahoma State in back-to-back weekends. WVU had 16 hits and did not make an error for the second-straight game.

    April 18, 2014

  • FURFARI COLUMN: Dr. Graber disagrees with Gee’s stance on Turnbull firing

    Dr. Stephen Graber, an associate professor at the West Virginia University School of Medicine, is among the latest WVU teachers to deplore Oliver Luck’s firing of veteran wrestling coach Craig Turnbull.
    He raised some significant questions about that issue last Monday in a meeting of the WVU Faculty Senate.

    April 18, 2014

  • Huggins signs junior college guard

    Coach Bob Huggins completed his 2014-15 West Virginia University recruiting class on Wednesday and deemed it a success after receiving a signed letter of intent from junior college guard Tarik Phillip.
    Phillip joins Jevon Carter of Maywood, Ill., and Daxter Miles of Baltimore’s Dunbar High and out of Notre Dame Prep in Massachusetts in the 2014-15 recruiting class.

    April 17, 2014

  • HERTZEL COLUMN: WVU gymnast hopes to stick her final landing

    The reaction, one suspects, was the same as most people who see either a picture of West Virginia University gymnast Hope Sloanhoffer or meet her for the first time in person — a quick double take, maybe even stumbling over the first few words of an introduction.

    April 17, 2014

  • FURFARI COLUMN: Comparing pay of coaches and professors

    Stringing together some odds and ends which may be of interest to you:
    • A beautiful lady came up to my table last Sunday at brunch in the Village of Heritage Point’s main dining room with a message.

    April 17, 2014

  • Bussie looks forward to WNBA

    On Tuesday, the weather turned cold, the wind blew and amongst the raindrops that fell a few snowflakes fluttered quietly to Earth.
    It was as if it was a celebration of Asya Bussie being drafted on Monday night by the Minnesota Lynx, champions of the WNBA, with the third selection of the second round, the 15th overall pick of the draft.

    April 16, 2014

  • WVU’s Harlee named Big 12 Scholar-Athlete

    The Big 12 Conference announced its Scholar-Athlete of the Year recipients for the 2014 winter sport season, and West Virginia University senior Jess Harlee earns the honor for women’s basketball.
    Harlee was selected as the award winner based on a vote of each respective sport’s head coaching group, with coaches not permitted to vote for their own student-athletes.

    April 16, 2014

  • Gyorko, Padres agree to extension

    Jedd Gyorko, who hasn’t hit much of anything with a .178 start on this season, hit the jackpot on Monday, signing a six-year contract extension with the San Diego Padres for $35 million with a one-year club option at $13 million.

    April 15, 2014

  • HERTZEL COLUMN- Spring game showed defense has improved

    From Dana Holgorsen’s viewpoint, which was standing right behind the offense, West Virginia’s Gold-Blue Spring Game on Saturday was a rousing success for it showed very little of what the Mountaineers will be in this coming season, probably not even showcasing the man who will direct the offense in the quarterback position.

    April 15, 2014

Featured Ads
WVU Sports Highlights
NDN Sports
House Ads
NCAA Breaking News
NCAA Photos